Varsity Extra

Softball all-conference teams released. Did your favorite player make the cut?

Saturday’s state championship round marked the end of the Idaho high school softball season. That means it’s award season, starting with the all-conference teams in the Treasure Valley.

See the all-conference teams in each league in Southwest Idaho below.

Coaches in each league select the teams. The Idaho Statesman publishes the results and plays no role in their selection.

Capital senior McKenna Chavez runs to first base for a single against Rocky Mountain in the 6A District Three softball tournament at Mountain View High School in Meridian, Monday, May 4, 2026.
Capital senior McKenna Chavez was voted the 6A Southern Idaho Conference Player of the year by the league’s softball coaches. Darin Oswald doswald@idahostatesman.com

6A SIC ALL-CONFERENCE SOFTBALL TEAM

Player of the Year: McKenna Chavez, sr., Capital

Coach of the Year: Tim Souza, Eagle

FIRST TEAM

P: Hailey Brennan, jr., Owyhee

P: Peyton Bargen, sr., Eagle

C: Kenadi Garrett, so., Owyhee

1B: Brooke Austin, jr., Mountain View

INF: Ellie McManigal, sr., Eagle

INF: Ali Knowles, sr., Mountain View

INF: Makenzie Owens, sr., Eagle

INF: Kamryn Newbery, so., Boise

OF: Alyssa Orchard, sr., Eagle

OF: Jovie Wilkins, so., Mountain View

OF: Hailey Bock, so., Owyhee

OF: Tayler Kloczko, sr., Rocky Mountain

UTIL: Aubrey Sorensen, sr., Rocky Mountain

DP: Giselle Aicher, so., Eagle

SECOND TEAM

P: Mya Penner, fr., Mountain View

P: Romy Turpen, fr., Capital

C: Polly McAllister, jr., Eagle

1B: Madalyn Mahaffey, so., Owyhee

INF: Breann Berg, so., Owyhee

INF: Reese Naylor, sr., Borah

INF: Courtney Austin, fr., Mountain View

INF: Bristol Reeves, so., Owyhee

OF: Kate Walsh, jr., Boise

OF: Olyvia Chalifoux, sr., Borah

OF: Saylor Shoemaker, sr., Owyhee

OF: Bailey Simpson, sr., Centennial

UTIL: Alexia Flygare, sr., Meridian

DP: Grace Groulx, so., Owyhee

HONORABLE MENTION

P: Sophia Giles, sr., Eagle

P: Keelyn Mardis, sr., Centennial

P: Kira Anderson, so., Boise

C: Genevieve Rainville, sr., Borah

C: Olivia Dow, so., Capital

C: Paisley Wiedenfeld, jr., Kuna

C: Emi Taylor, so., Ridgevue

1B: Brooke Frame, sr., Eagle

1B: Darlene Espinoza, so., Capital

1B: Josie Gregory, sr., Borah

INF: Ivy Norskog, so., Timberline

INF: Reagan Morris, jr., Meridian

INF: Cali Moorhouse, sr., Centennial

INF: Elle Wemhoff, jr., Kuna

INF: Erin Thoreson, jr., Eagle

INF: Olli Fuchs, jr., Capital

INF: Lauren Wontorcik, so., Boise

OF: Breanna Duncan, jr., Timberline

OF: Reese Northcut, jr., Eagle

OF: Sophia Giles, sr., Eagle

OF: Nia Hall, so., Mountain View

OF: Genevieve Tessmer, so., Capital

OF: Avery Simpson, so., Centennial

OF: Kareena Nelson, fr., Ridgevue

UTIL: Kendal Holloway, fr., Ridgevue

UTIL: Justice Pruitt, sr., Borah

UTIL: Charlize Veldhouse, jr., Centennial

DP: Megan McCormick, so., Rocky Mountain

DP: Hannah Featherly, fr., Centennial

5A SIC ALL-CONFERENCE SOFTBALL TEAM

Player of the Year: Oakley Scheibe, jr., Emmett

Coach of the Year: Kevin Schimmelpfennig, Vallivue

FIRST TEAM

P: Libby Garcia, so., Middleton

P: Kaylee Mathson, sr., Nampa

C: Ella McMullen, jr., Skyview

1B: Gracie Cammann, jr., Bishop Kelly

INF: Abbie Eggleston, jr., Vallivue

INF: Grace Chambers, so., Skyview

INF: Kingsley Shea, so., Bishop Kelly

INF: Josie Cunningham, sr., Bishop Kelly

OF: Olivia Watt, jr., Bishop Kelly

OF: Lily Bittinger, sr., Skyview

OF: Kennly Leuthold, jr., Vallivue

OF: Jaynie Burke, so., Bishop Kelly

UTIL: Ashya Fried, sr., Middleton

UTIL: Kenna Bettencourt, sr., Skyview

DH: Khloe Howard, fr., Skyview

SECOND TEAM

P: Maris Farner, sr., Vallivue

P: Averi Gustafson, so., Middleton

C: Kenadi Whitlow, jr., Middleton

1B: Evonny Gonzales, sr., Vallivue

INF: Haylee Hultner, so., Middleton

INF: Payten Hutsell, jr., Nampa

INF: Kaylee Mathson, sr., Nampa

INF: Audrey Clements, jr., Skyview

OF: Sarah Reveles, sr., Nampa

OF: Krysta Alder, sr., Emmett

OF: Sydney Qualls, jr., Middleton

OF: Sophia Kassotis, so., Vallivue

UTIL: Khloe Wright, jr., Bishop Kelly

UTIL: Khloe Flygare, fr., Vallivue

DH: Addison Aguila, so., Vallivue

HONORABLE MENTION

P: Makenna Shamy, jr., Skyview

P: Bristol Runnels, jr., Caldwell

P: Riley Fowler, fr., Emmett

C: Daysia Chavez, sr., Nampa

C: Averie Reynolds, jr., Emmett

1B: Makayla Lytle, sr., Skyview

1B: Addie McPherson, so., Middleton

1B: Kaycee Pinto, sr., Emmett

INF: Bristol Runnels, jr., Caldwell

INF: Chloe Scott, jr., Emmett

INF: Olivia Godina, sr., Caldwell

INF: Maci Haskins, fr., Emmett

INF: Shay Hermansen, sr., Middleton

INF: Averi Gustafson, so., Middleton

OF: Kamryn Becker, jr., Middleton

OF: Terese Stroschein, sr., Bishop Kelly

OF: Khloe Arce, so., Caldwell

OF: Ella Corner, jr., Caldwell

UTIL: Kollyns Gragg, fr., Emmett

DH: Natalie Lange, jr., Bishop Kelly

4A SRV ALL-CONFERENCE SOFTBALL TEAM

Coming soon

3A WIC ALL-CONFERENCE SOFTBALL TEAM

Player of the Year: Peyton Shook, sr., Nampa Christian

Coach of the Year: Justin Shook, Nampa Christian

FIRST TEAM

Addison Gray, sr., Nampa Christian

Brooklyn Roadenbaugh, sr., Marsing

Analyse Durham, sr., Melba

Kinlea Cole, so., Parma

Wesli Crockett, sr., Parma

Makiah Weideman, sr., New Plymouth

Quenna Hartley, fr., Nampa Christian

Myranda Van Vliet, so., Nampa Christian

Nalani Van Tuyl, fr., Parma

Maya Jensen, sr., Parma

SECOND TEAM

Bailey Daugherty, sr., Marsing

Olivia Visser, so., New Plymouth

Averi Albisu, jr., New Plymouth

Poppy Nichols, so., Parma

Ashlynn Swank, jr., Nampa Christian

Aubrey Burns, fr., Nampa Christian

Kylie Britton, jr., Parma

Kaitlyn Kinzler, fr., Nampa Christian

Olivia Atack, jr., Melba

Elle Crimbchin, sr., Melba

HONORABLE MENTION

Danylle Daugherty, jr., Marsing

Maylee Astorquia, so., Marsing

Kyla Harris, so., Melba

Andrea Pinto, fr., Melba

Macy Boothby, sr., Nampa Christian

Chloe Shook, fr., Nampa Christian

Avery Jones, so., New Plymouth

Landyn Jenkins, so., New Plymouth

Aliyah Jaxon, fr., Parma

Sawyer Watkins, so., Parma

2A WIC ALL-CONFERENCE SOFTBALL TEAM

Coming soon

Michael Lycklama
Idaho Statesman
Michael Lycklama has covered Idaho high school sports since 2007. He’s won national awards for his work uncovering the stories of the Treasure Valley’s best athletes and investigating behind-the-scenes trends. If you like seeing stories like this, please consider supporting our work with a digital subscription to the Idaho Statesman. Support my work with a digital subscription
Get unlimited digital access
#ReadLocal

Try 1 month for $1

CLAIM OFFER