Idaho’s planned 2018 grizzly bear hunt was delayed, at least, Thursday by a federal judge. Idaho had issued one tag for a hunt that would have started Saturday, Sept. 1.
U.S. District Judge Dana Christensen issued the much-anticipated ruling Thursday in Missoula, Mont., granting a temporary restraining order for at least 14 days. The decision stops hunts in Idaho and Wyoming. Montana had decided to skip a hunt this year. Grizzlies haven’t been hunted in the Lower 48 states since Montana’s hunt in 1991, according to The Associated Press.
The decision was part of an attempt to overturn the federal government’s 2017 decision to remove endangered species protection from the Greater Yellowstone grizzly bears.
“We applaud Judge Christensen’s decision to hit the pause button,” Matthew Bishop, an attorney with the Western Environmental Law Center, said in a press release. “There is simply no need to rush into a grizzly bear hunt, with potentially devastating consequences for this iconic species, when the merits of that hunt are being reviewed in federal court.”
Sign Up and Save
Get six months of free digital access to The Idaho Statesman
The original post below was published July 2, 2018.
One of the most unusual — and perhaps controversial — hunts in Idaho history is scheduled to occur this fall.
Idaho Fish and Game will hold a lottery for one grizzly bear tag for the 2018 season. The deadline to apply is July 15, and the August draw is limited to Idaho residents. It’s still possible the hunt will be canceled depending on the outcome of a federal court hearing in August in Montana. Idaho’s hunt begins Sept. 1.
Here’s why and where the hunt is happening, what the hunter can expect and why Idaho is limited to one tag.
Why is a grizzly hunt happening now?
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service removed the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem grizzly bears from the endangered list in 2017, giving Idaho, Wyoming and Montana more management responsibility. Hunting will be allowed when the population exceeds 600 bears. The 2017 population estimate was 718 in the Yellowstone demographic monitoring area, according to Idaho Fish and Game — up from fewer than 200 in the 1970s.
The population has ranged from 694 to 757 over the past decade in a DMA that includes Yellowstone and Grand Teton national parks, where hunting won’t be allowed.
Idaho Fish and Game received more than 900 comments while considering its grizzly season. The majority favored the hunt, according to the department. Fish and Game commissioners approved the hunt in May.
“It’s an absolute sign of success that we have recovered grizzly bears in the past 40 years,” said Toby Boudreau, assistant chief of wildlife for Idaho Fish and Game. “Hats off to all the people that have made that happen. Having a hunt, that is a sure sign that the species has recovered.”
Idaho’s season will run from Sept. 1 to Nov. 15. The limit is one bear. No female accompanied by a cub, or young bear accompanied by an adult, may be taken. The hunt will take place in portions of hunting units 61, 62 and 62A, in the Island Park area of East Idaho.
How did Idaho decide on one grizzly tag?
Grizzly tags for the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem are set based on acceptable mortality for the grizzly population. Of the bears available for hunting, Wyoming gets 58 percent, Montana gets 34 percent and Idaho gets 8 percent, based on the proportion of the land in the demographic monitoring area. The percentages don’t include Yellowstone and Grand Teton land.
Idaho was allocated 1.3 bears, Boudreau said, which was rounded down to one. Wyoming approved a 2018 hunt but Montana did not.
Who can apply? How much does it cost?
Only Idaho residents with valid hunting licenses can apply. There’s a non-refundable application fee of $16.75 and each applicant must prepay for the tag, which is $199.75 or $166.75 depending on the hunter’s Price Lock status. Tag fees are refunded to unsuccessful applicants. If the hunt is canceled, the application and license fees won’t be refunded.
Grizzly harvest is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity. A successful hunter can’t apply again.
How much interest has Fish and Game received?
As of late last week, 379 hunters had applied for the grizzly hunt. That’s low compared to the nearly 170,000 applicants who participated in the draw for controlled hunts involving deer, elk and antelope last year. The low odds of getting a grizzly tag likely have played a role, Boudreau said.
What will the hunt be like?
“Lots of glassing, is what they’re in for,” Boudreau said. “They’ll spend a lot of time behind binoculars and a spotting scope looking for bears in open areas. ... If the bears choose to stay in that forested habitat, it’s going to be challenging. It’s not impossible to get close to a grizzly bear, but it’s going to take some skill for somebody to get close.”
The hunter has a choice of weapons but most likely would choose a rifle, Boudreau said. Baiting, electric calls and use of dogs won’t be allowed.
“There’s enough bears there that people would have a high likelihood of seeing bears,” Boudreau said. “Whether they can put it all together to harvest a bear, it’s not going to be by any stretch an easy hunt.”
What kind of assistance will the hunter receive?
Because of the special nature of the hunt, Fish and Game will spend some time educating the hunter — with an emphasis on distinguishing between male and female grizzlies. The preference is for the hunter to take a male bear.
“We do not want people taking females that could have cubs,” Boudreau said. “They aren’t always right there with them, so if you’re able to help somebody learn how to identify a female, then the chances of taking one that might have cubs with it is greatly decreased. ... We’ll try to give them the benefit of our knowledge and the resources that are available to help them be successful.”
Does Idaho have grizzly bears elsewhere?
Yes. Smaller populations of grizzlies, still listed as endangered, live in the Selkirk and Cabinet mountains of North Idaho.