Business Insider

Water-rights victory made this Idaho ranch owner a ‘rock star’

Idaho's oldest family ranch still runs cattle in Owyhee County

The Joyce Ranch near Murphy is more than 150 years old. It's owner, Paul Nettleton, claims it's the oldest ranch in Idaho. He works with his son, Chad Nettleton, who is the fifth generation of family to operate the Owyhee County ranch in southwest
Up Next
The Joyce Ranch near Murphy is more than 150 years old. It's owner, Paul Nettleton, claims it's the oldest ranch in Idaho. He works with his son, Chad Nettleton, who is the fifth generation of family to operate the Owyhee County ranch in southwest

Improved equipment, nutrition and data-driven ranch management have changed the cow-and-calf game since Matthew Joyce established the Joyce Ranch near Murphy 152 years ago.

But winter is still cold and dust is still dry, and Paul Nettleton, the ranch’s 67-year-old, fourth-generation owner, still throws ornery calves to the ground the way his great-grandfather did.

When his ranch hand roped only one calf leg on a 92-degree day in June, Nettleton pulled the bellowing calf’s tail one way and leaned his shoulder into its rear hip until it toppled. Nettleton, his 37-year-old son and partner, Chad Nettleton, and another hand gave the calf a shot and checked it for pink eye. Once the job was done, the team repeated the steps with another calf.

“I remember the old ways, the way we used to do things,” Nettleton says. “[Chad] has a more modern look at things. I’m not sure it’s any better.”

Both men smile.

The Owyhee Cattlemen’s Association, the oldest such group in the state, says the Joyce Livestock Co. is the oldest family-owned ranch in Idaho.

Like most Western ranch companies, Joyce runs cattle on federal lands along with its own. That has led to conflicts. Paul Nettleton took the federal government to court 10 years ago and won, protecting ranchers’ water rights in a ruling the Idaho Farm Bureau said has helped ranchers across the West.

A GOLD RUSH LURES A HOMESTEADER

The ranch began after the discovery of gold in the Owyhee Mountains during the Civil War.

Matthew Joyce, a native of Ireland, moved from Nevada and established a homestead on Sinker Creek, a Snake River tributary south of Murphy, to farm and sell food to gold miners. The creek basin is a narrow stip of green bounded by steep gulch walls with sagebrush desert above.

Sinker Creek was unsurveyed in 1865, which meant Joyce could not establish a formal homestead to own the land, Nettleton says. Squatter’s rights dictated who owned what, and a man named Scotch Bob Davidson was already at Sinker Creek when Joyce arrived.

But Davidson traveled, as did Joyce, so the men agreed to be neighbors to ensure that other squatters could not move onto the area while they were away.

0719 joyceranch07
A cattle hand moves a herd of cattle into corrals at the Joyce Ranch near Murphy. Darin Oswald doswald@idahostatesman.com

The first Joyce house was built close to the creek and ruined by a flood from spring runoff. The second burned down, forcing Joyce into the chicken coop. He added to that coop over the years, and it remains the oldest structure on the ranch.

Joyce had four sons, but none married. His daughter, Maggie Joyce Nettleton, was the only one in her generation to have children and live on the ranch. Nettletons have run the ranch ever since.

In 1943, a dam that had been built on Sinker Creek collapsed, resulting in a 40-foot-high wall of water that leveled much of the ranch. It was rebuilt.

Today, Paul Nettleton owns 5,000 acres in the basin and 7,000 disconnected acres scattered around the area. The family’s cattle also graze on 120,000 acres of federal land stretching around Silver City 20 miles away, where a young Paul Nettleton traveled on horseback for supplies.

In 2015, the family had about 600 cows that gave birth to about 600 calves.

This year, the herd suffered during the long, snowy winter, leading weak cows to give birth to weak calves. The Nettletons rounded up newborns and brought them to the ranch to recuperate. Still, about 200 died.

“In all of my years here — and that’s all of them — I’d never seen more than 18 inches of snow,” Paul Nettleton says. “We topped out at 20.”

The losses will hurt 2017 sales come auction time. The Nettletons do not disclose revenues.

PAUL NETTLETON GOES TO COURT

In 2007, Joyce Livestock Co. and another Owyhee County family ranch, LU Ranching Co., won a lawsuit against the U.S. Bureau of Land Management for access to water on federal grazing land.

Joyce and the government had each filed claims to lands abutting Jordan Creek, an Owyhee River tributary that flows west into Oregon. Joyce’s claim came first, but the government said a subsequent federal law let the government appropriate it.

Water claims are valuable assets for businesses. Securing access allows ranchers to plan how to manage their operations, including the right to divert water, says John Thompson, director of communications at the Idaho Farm Bureau.

The Idaho Supreme Court upheld a lower-court ruling that the government could not take the water rights. The court said the BLM’s argument “reflects a misunderstanding of water law.” The U.S. Supreme Court turned down the government’s appeal.

Had the government won, rights to use water on other federal lands would have been jeopardized, Thompson says.

“They are patriots,” Thompson says. “They just said, ‘Hell no. We won’t let this happen.’”

But the Idaho Supreme Court denied Paul Nettleton’s request for legal fees. The government presented “a legitimate issue” not previously resolved by courts, not a frivolous case, the court said.

The Farm Bureau held fundraisers and solicited donations from cattle groups around the country for the Nettletons, but those efforts generated little.

“They won a battle in the courtroom for cattlemen all over the West, but they lost in the grand scheme of things,” Thompson says.

0719 joyceranch06
The ranch turned 150 years old in June 2015. Darin Oswald doswald@idahostatesman.com

Standing up to the federal government will be Paul Nettleton’s legacy, says Garth Taylor, an agricultural economist at the University of Idaho.

“He’s a folk hero, a rock star,” Taylor says. “He will live on in history for that one thing.”

Today, Paul Nettleton says, federal land managers still pose the greatest risk to the ranch.

“We have overgrown grasses on the range,” he says. “We have range protected that doesn’t need to be. We have fire dangers like crazy. In the good old days, we’d have this grass grazed down at least enough that fire wouldn’t spread very fast.”

THE FUTURE

His son, Chad, has gradually taken over day-to-day ranch operations.

Like his father, Chad Nettleton learned to ride a horse shortly after learning to walk. He remembers spending his youth helping to irrigate fields, driving the feed truck and trapping gophers.

As the only boy, Nettleton says he “always kind of assumed” he’d one day take over the ranch. He worked several jobs in Moscow, including roofing, while attending the University of Idaho, where he majored in agricultural systems management with a minor in agricultural economics.

“The thought of ranching here as being my only job, of not having many other experiences when there’s a big world out there, seemed a little stifling,” he says.

By the time he graduated, though, Chad Nettleton says he knew his heart was in Sinker Creek.

“When I got older, I realized this is pretty different from what most people do every day,” he says. “It’s a great life. It’s a great way to raise kids. It’s not so much as a job as a lifestyle.”

Paul Nettleton expects his son to own the ranch eventually.

Chad Nettleton has two sons, Jarret, 3, and Case, 2. They live in a house on the ranch about a mile from where Paul lives. Chad Nettleton and his father hope that a sixth generation will one day run Joyce Ranch, too.

“I raise them doing this stuff,” Chad Nettleton says. “You hope they take an interest. I’m pretty sure that at least one of them and maybe even both will want to keep the tradition going.”

Business Editor David Staats contributed. This story appears in the July 19-August 15, 2017, edition of the Idaho Statesman’s Business Insider magazine as part of a special section on agriculture. Click here for the Statesman’s e-edition, which includes Business Insider (subscription required).

  Comments