Idaho Statesman Logo

Commentary: Why California court will uphold Prop 8 | Idaho Statesman

×
  • E-edition
  • Home
    • Customer Service
    • Mobile & Apps
    • Archives
    • Buy Photos and Pages
    • Contact Us
    • Newsletters
    • Newspaper in Education
    • Subscribe
    • Subscriber Services

    • News
    • Boise
    • West Ada
    • Canyon County
    • Crime
    • State News
    • Nation/World News
    • Databases
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Idahoans in the Military
    • Weather
    • Traffic
    • Helping Works
    • In the Classroom
    • Our Community
    • Sports
    • Boise State Football
    • Boise State Basketball
    • Idaho Vandals
    • High Schools
    • Bronco Beat
    • Chadd Cripe
    • Varsity Extra Blog
    • NFL
    • NBA
    • NHL
    • MLB
    • Golf
    • Idaho Politics
    • Elections
    • Government and Business
    • Capitol & State
    • Letters from the West
    • National Politics
    • Business
    • Business Insider
    • Business Columns & Blogs
    • Personal Finance
    • Legal Notices
    • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Bill Manny
    • Editorial Cartoons
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Guest Opinion
    • Submit a Letter or Opinion
    • Entertainment
    • Events Calendar
    • Restaurant Reviews
    • Arts and Culture
    • Festivals
    • Movie Reviews
    • Movie Showtimes
    • Music
    • Television
    • Books
    • Comics
    • Puzzles & Games
    • Horoscopes
    • Puzzles
    • Words & Deeds
    • ArtsBeat
    • Outdoors
    • Playing Outdoors Blog
    • Biking
    • Camping
    • Fishing
    • Hiking and Trails
    • Hunting
    • Winter Recreation
    • Living
    • Food & Drink
    • Health & Fitness
    • Home & Garden
    • Treasure
    • Pets
    • Religion
    • Travel
    • Best of Treasure Valley
    • Heart of the Treasure Valley
    • Margaret Lauterbach
    • Tim Woodward
    • Carolyn Hax
  • Obituaries

  • Contests
  • Advertise
  • Classifieds
  • Jobs
  • Cars
  • Homes
  • Place An Ad

  • About Us
  • Mobile & Apps

News

Commentary: Why California court will uphold Prop 8

Peter Schrag - The Sacramento Bee

    ORDER REPRINT →

March 17, 2009 09:01 AM

There've been decades of complaint that the great flood of ballot measures confronting California voters could be reduced and simplified if the state Supreme Court more strictly enforced the constitution's rule against voter initiatives covering more than one subject or revising (not just amending) the constitution.

Almost a decade ago, Chief Justice Ron George showed increasing impatience with the glut of initiative cases landing on the court's docket and hinted that the justices might just be ready to do that. The case argued earlier this month challenging Proposition 8, the initiative passed last November declaring gay marriage invalid in California, gave the court its best chance in years. At the heart of the challenge was the argument that in undermining the constitution's equal protection scheme, Proposition 8 is indeed a revision, not a mere amendment. That could have provided the court a great opportunity to send a signal that future initiatives will be scrutinized more strictly, as courts do in some other states.

But it's not likely to happen. Judging from the drift of the justices' questions, the safest bet – always with cautions about the unpredictability of such wagers – is that the court will uphold Proposition 8. Both George and Justice Joyce Kennard, who were part of the 4-3 majority striking down California's statutory prohibition of same-sex marriages last May, seemed ready to join the three dissenters in that case and uphold the initiative that in effect reversed that ruling. Kennard was a dissenter in a prior case removing an initiative (on redistricting) from the ballot. She also voted against hearing the Proposition 8 challenge.

In his earlier statements, among them remarks at a conference at the University of Santa Clara Law School in 2001, George declared that "the evolution of the initiative process has had a profound effect on the courts," both in the volume of cases and in the task of interpreting measures that, unlike ordinary laws, have no legislative history to guide the judges. Those problems, he indicated then, would lead the court to look more carefully at challenged initiatives.

Sign Up and Save

Get six months of free digital access to The Idaho Statesman

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

#ReadLocal

But in the arguments this month, it was the defender of Proposition 8, Dean Kenneth Starr of the Pepperdine University Law School, best remembered as the special prosecutor who ginned up the case leading to President Bill Clinton's impeachment in 1998, who seemed to have the court's most sympathetic attention.

To read the complete article, visit www.sacbee.com.

Related stories from Idaho Statesman

news

Hundreds turn out for Cal. Supreme Court hearing on Prop 8

March 06, 2009 04:41 AM

news

Commentary: A pain-filled debate over Prop 8

March 10, 2009 02:41 AM

  Comments  

Videos

Key moments since Jussie Smollett reported attack

Fastest growing jobs in the United States through 2024

View More Video

Trending Stories

Boise Hawks’ stadium to host big rock festival. Free beer in ticket price? Cheers, punk

February 19, 2019 11:58 AM

The million-dollar Boise home? Ho-hum. See who’s buying houses for $2 million and up

February 19, 2019 10:18 AM

Stick this in your pipe and smoke it, Utah! Idaho is one of least sinful U.S. states

February 20, 2019 04:04 PM

Boise businessman said franchiser double-crossed him. What Idaho’s Supreme Court ruled

February 20, 2019 02:16 PM

Cold case breakthrough: Man charged with murder in 1995 death of Idaho teen

February 20, 2019 05:09 PM

Read Next

Texas billionaires put more Idaho land on the market. Here’s how much they still own.

Environment

Texas billionaires put more Idaho land on the market. Here’s how much they still own.

By Nicole Blanchard

    ORDER REPRINT →

February 21, 2019 05:00 AM

Texas billionaire brothers Dan and Farris Wilks last year began selling some of the thousands of acres of Idaho land they bought in 2016. Two Idahoans purchased parcels near McCall, and more is for sale.

KEEP READING

Sign Up and Save

#ReadLocal

Get six months of free digital access to The Idaho Statesman

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

MORE NEWS

Pope offers 21 proposals to fight abuse at start of summit

Nation & World

Pope offers 21 proposals to fight abuse at start of summit

February 21, 2019 08:53 AM
Police: ‘Empire’ actor staged attack to ‘promote his career’

Entertainment

Police: ‘Empire’ actor staged attack to ‘promote his career’

February 21, 2019 08:55 AM
Syracuse coach Jim Boeheim reportedly struck and killed a man on Interstate

National

Syracuse coach Jim Boeheim reportedly struck and killed a man on Interstate

February 21, 2019 07:54 AM
The Latest: Police: Smollett sent racist letter to himself

Entertainment

The Latest: Police: Smollett sent racist letter to himself

February 21, 2019 08:22 AM
US home sales tumbled 1.2 percent in January

Business

US home sales tumbled 1.2 percent in January

February 21, 2019 08:09 AM
Saint Al’s didn’t file Medicare claims for a year. What does that mean for patients?

Business

Saint Al’s didn’t file Medicare claims for a year. What does that mean for patients?

February 21, 2019 07:20 AM
Take Us With You

Real-time updates and all local stories you want right in the palm of your hand.

Icon for mobile apps

Idaho Statesman App

View Newsletters

Subscriptions
  • Start a Subscription
  • Customer Service
  • eEdition
  • Vacation Hold
  • Pay Your Bill
  • Rewards
Learn More
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletters
  • News in Education
  • Archives
Advertising
  • Information
  • Place a Classified
  • Local Deals
  • Place an Obituary
  • Today's Circulars
Copyright
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service


Back to Story