Idaho Statesman Logo

'Buy American' isn't new, but is it really a good idea? | Idaho Statesman

×
  • E-edition
  • Home
    • Customer Service
    • Mobile & Apps
    • Archives
    • Buy Photos and Pages
    • Contact Us
    • Newsletters
    • Newspaper in Education
    • Subscribe
    • Subscriber Services

    • News
    • Boise
    • West Ada
    • Canyon County
    • Crime
    • State News
    • Nation/World News
    • Databases
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Idahoans in the Military
    • Weather
    • Traffic
    • Helping Works
    • In the Classroom
    • Our Community
    • Sports
    • Boise State Football
    • Boise State Basketball
    • Idaho Vandals
    • High Schools
    • Bronco Beat
    • Chadd Cripe
    • Varsity Extra Blog
    • NFL
    • NBA
    • NHL
    • MLB
    • Golf
    • Idaho Politics
    • Elections
    • Government and Business
    • Capitol & State
    • Letters from the West
    • National Politics
    • Business
    • Business Insider
    • Business Columns & Blogs
    • Personal Finance
    • Legal Notices
    • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Bill Manny
    • Editorial Cartoons
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Guest Opinion
    • Submit a Letter or Opinion
    • Entertainment
    • Events Calendar
    • Restaurant Reviews
    • Arts and Culture
    • Festivals
    • Movie Reviews
    • Movie Showtimes
    • Music
    • Television
    • Books
    • Comics
    • Puzzles & Games
    • Horoscopes
    • Puzzles
    • Words & Deeds
    • ArtsBeat
    • Outdoors
    • Playing Outdoors Blog
    • Biking
    • Camping
    • Fishing
    • Hiking and Trails
    • Hunting
    • Winter Recreation
    • Living
    • Food & Drink
    • Health & Fitness
    • Home & Garden
    • Treasure
    • Pets
    • Religion
    • Travel
    • Best of Treasure Valley
    • Heart of the Treasure Valley
    • Margaret Lauterbach
    • Tim Woodward
    • Carolyn Hax
  • Obituaries

  • Contests
  • Advertise
  • Classifieds
  • Jobs
  • Cars
  • Homes
  • Place An Ad

  • About Us
  • Mobile & Apps

News

'Buy American' isn't new, but is it really a good idea?

Kevin G. Hall - McClatchy Newspapers

    ORDER REPRINT →

February 03, 2009 05:37 PM

WASHINGTON — "Buy American" provisions in the economic stimulus legislation moving through Congress have foreign leaders threatening retaliation and academics warning that the globe could soon go through the kind of tit-for-tat protectionism that helped deepen the Great Depression.

The stimulus bill passed by the House of Representatives and the Senate measure being voted on this week contain a provision that directs builders and general contractors to use only U.S.-made steel and iron.

Proponents insist that these provisions already exist in U.S. law and simply echo a 1982 policy that requires federal transportation spending to favor U.S.-made iron, steel and manufactured goods.

Opponents warn that these terms in the stimulus legislation may violate international trade treaties and present an affront to nations already reeling from entanglement in America's financial-market meltdown.

Sign Up and Save

Get six months of free digital access to The Idaho Statesman

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

#ReadLocal

Both are right.

In today's interconnected — and badly bruised — world, the perception of rising protectionism in Washington may be as important as a reality that suggests otherwise.

A number of economic stimulus programs are being forged in capitals around the world — from Beijing and London to Brasilia and Canberra — that could launch a new wave of what some will call protectionism, others self preservation. If they emulate the U.S. "Buy American" national favoritism, not only will U.S. firms miss opportunities to sell to them, but the pattern of closing off commerce to non-nationals could expand.

The Buy America provision "is starting small, but of course our whole financial crisis started small, with subprime (mortgages). You've got the same thing in the trade area — you can start small, but it is a license to every country to protect" its domestic industries, said Gary Hufbauer, a senior fellow for the Peterson Institute for International Economics, a pro-trade research organization.

Indeed, that's the pattern of history in the missteps that helped bring about the Great Depression. Congress passed the Smoot-Hawley Act in 1930, raising to record levels the tariffs on more than 20,000 imported goods.

European nations responded in kind. The tit-for-tat nationalistic trade war brought a plunge in commerce between nations, and rising hardship fed nationalistic tensions that eventually erupted into War World II.

Many U.S. trading partners will be judging the final shape of America's stimulus legislation as a measure of President Barack Obama's worldview.

"If Buy America becomes part of the stimulus legislation, the United States will lose the moral authority to pressure others not to introduce protectionist policies," warned Michael Wilson, Canada's ambassador to the U.S., in a letter this week to Senate leaders.

Complaints from Canada, China and Europe have all hinted at retaliation. However, proponents of the "Buy America" language in the stimulus legislation are correct in saying these provisions are nothing new.

The stimulus language is virtually identical to a number of U.S. laws, most notably the 2005 reauthorization of funding for highway programs. The highway bill language and the terms in the stimulus legislation are identical in restricting funds from use in projects "unless all of the iron, steel, and manufactured goods used in the project are produced in the United States."

The new language is also identical in how waivers to the rules are granted — by presidential decree, if materials are unavailable in the U.S. or if they would raise the cost by 25 percent or more.

The only substantive difference in the stimulus legislation as introduced is a requirement that the reasons for granting a waiver be published in the Federal Register.

So if this language just repeats existing law, what's the problem? Why all this talk of trade wars and a return to the Great Depression?

"They're constructing a scenario that is not going to happen in the real world," said Scott Paul, executive director of the Alliance for American Manufacturing, a lobby group for small U.S. manufacturers and steelworker unions. "What I think is happening here is a lot of bluster on this issue to try to leverage the Obama administration on more pressing issues down the road."

That's because during the presidential campaign, Obama was cool to free trade. A new round of global trade liberalization has been deadlocked for several years, and in this time of crisis, Americans aren't exactly begging for it.

"People need to understand their chances of talking the American public out of this kind of attitude are zero," Rep. Barney Frank, D-Mass., chairman of the influential House Financial Services Committee, told reporters Tuesday. "There is now a deeply rooted anger on the part of the average American at what he or she thinks is a very unfair set of arrangements."

The Obama administration, besieged with problems getting appointees confirmed, is trying to keep a foot in both camps of the Buy American debate.

"We're looking at the specific provisions and the specific language," Larry Summers, the head of Obama's National Economic Council, told reporters Tuesday. "But the president's been very clear that he wants this to be a bill that supports the American economy, but at the same time his bill is not going to be an excuse for America breaking its international commitments or embracing any new kind of protectionism."

(Lisa Zagaroli contributed to this article.)

ON THE WEB

2005 revision of the 1958 highway authorizations

Buy American provisions in stimulus bill

Alliance for American Manufacturing view

Peterson Institute report

MORE FROM MCCLATCHY

To ask a question about this story or any economic question, go to McClatchy's economy Q&A

Will tax breaks in stimulus bill save jobs? No one knows

Obama turns to grassroots to sway Senate on stimulus

GOP votes unswayed by Obama lobbying on stimulus bill

  Comments  

Videos

See four familiar retailers filing for bankruptcy

Idaho Youth Ranch sees an uptick in donations due to popular Netflix show

View More Video

Trending Stories

Stick this in your pipe and smoke it, Utah! Idaho is one of least sinful U.S. states

February 20, 2019 04:04 PM

Cold case breakthrough: Man charged with murder in 1995 death of Idaho teen

February 20, 2019 05:09 PM

Amazon’s Nampa center will increase traffic, so city wants it to pay for road upgrades

February 20, 2019 12:03 AM

Idaho internet speed? Nearly worst in U.S. Here’s how we improve (if this @%# page loads)

February 21, 2019 12:23 PM

Texas billionaires put more Idaho land on the market. Here’s how much they still own.

February 21, 2019 05:00 AM

Read Next

China says coal handling delayed by environmental checks

Business

China says coal handling delayed by environmental checks

By NICK PERRY Associated Press

    ORDER REPRINT →

February 22, 2019 03:04 AM

China says delays in handling of Australian coal due to environmental checks.

KEEP READING

Sign Up and Save

#ReadLocal

Get six months of free digital access to The Idaho Statesman

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

MORE NEWS

Nation & World

Kenya court postpones ruling on anti-gay laws to May 24

February 22, 2019 03:03 AM

Business

Louisiana governor releases his new budget proposal Friday

February 22, 2019 03:00 AM
Russian opens money laundering probe involving Moldova

Nation & World

Russian opens money laundering probe involving Moldova

February 22, 2019 02:59 AM
Vatican summit on sex abuse focuses calls for accountability

Nation & World

Vatican summit on sex abuse focuses calls for accountability

February 22, 2019 02:59 AM
India top court orders an end to assaults against Kashmiris

Nation & World

India top court orders an end to assaults against Kashmiris

February 22, 2019 02:57 AM

National Politics

FSA loans open to 31 Louisiana parishes, 9 counties

February 22, 2019 02:55 AM
Take Us With You

Real-time updates and all local stories you want right in the palm of your hand.

Icon for mobile apps

Idaho Statesman App

View Newsletters

Subscriptions
  • Start a Subscription
  • Customer Service
  • eEdition
  • Vacation Hold
  • Pay Your Bill
  • Rewards
Learn More
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletters
  • News in Education
  • Archives
Advertising
  • Information
  • Place a Classified
  • Local Deals
  • Place an Obituary
  • Today's Circulars
Copyright
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service


Back to Story