Ask Amy: Two sons engage in romantic drama

Tribune Media News ServiceJuly 5, 2014 

Dear Amy: We have two sons, "Paul," 36, and "Michael," 33. Paul finally married his long-term girlfriend "Tasha" after a long and tempestuous relationship marked by bitter breakups and tearful returns - with one arrest along the way.

They dragged the family along on their adventure, and it has not been a pleasant trip.

During one of Paul's breakups, Paul met a very nice girl, "Nancy." We all liked Nancy but Tasha was having none of it. She bulldozed her way back into the picture and that was the end of sweet Nancy. This happened three years ago.

Our youngest son, Michael, lives in a small cabin on our property. He ran into Nancy and (surprise, surprise) they have started seeing each other. They have been out three times and seem to like each other.

He has not had any long-term relationships; he suffers from an autism spectrum disorder, and relationships can be difficult for him. He is really a very kindhearted, soft-spoken, gentle soul.

My husband and I are thrilled he is dating Nancy, but terrified of the consequences when Paul figures this out. Worse yet, when his wife, Tasha, gets wind of this, life will be hell again. She can be quite nasty. A sweet girl like Nancy would be no match for her.

It is summer now and probably the only time they would all be together would be Thanksgiving. Any suggestions?


Dear Worried: You all need to wait to see if "Michael" and "Nancy" develop a longer-term relationship (three dates may not signify much). If so, Michael should tell his brother privately - and if he asks for your help, you should mentor him from the sidelines.

"Tasha's" behavior might be fuel for your son's passion, but that doesn't mean you need to show the same involvement or tolerance as he does (your comment about "one arrest along the way" puts this relationship in the extreme category).

At this point, you know enough about Tasha to anticipate trouble. This time, don't go along on her thrill ride. Do not engage with her or "Paul" about this, and if either of them harasses Michael or Nancy and you feel they can't protect themselves, then you should stand up to these bullies yourself.

Dear Amy: I have fallen in love with a funny, smart, kind man who is good to me. He is the love of my life, and we want to plan a future together. There's only one problem: In the five years we've known each other, he hasn't kept any job for very long. He's also in school, and is not super successful at that.

I have worked hard and have gone into debt to be where I am. I have a steady job, but I don't make much money and I won't be able to support us both.

I find it hard to bring up my fears about our financial future.

I don't want money to be the reason we can't be together, and I'm embarrassed to say it's important to me, but its importance has already made itself known.

Should I tell him I can't be with him until he can succeed financially?


Dear Distraught: Five years of being with someone should tell you everything important you need to know.

Your guy is funny, smart and kind. You love him.

If you two are going to be together very long-term, you will be the breadwinner. This means that you will have to get a different job where you make enough to support both of you while he does what he can to supplement this with temporary excursions into the job force.

This reality isn't the end of the world - men have been taking on the breadwinner role for eons, and if you make a family with your guy, you can do it too.

Dear Amy: I love the way you take the "drama" out of the questions to which you respond, and focus on the core issues that transcend the politically charged topics. Thank you.


DEAR LARRY: "Taking the drama out" is sort of like taking out the trash. Periodically, you have to leave it at the curb.

Idaho Statesman is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service