Otter aims to heal GOP for November

Losing Idaho's three most populous counties shows that the governor is vulnerable, his Democratic opponent says. 2014 Idaho StatesmanMay 22, 2014 

  • More names emerge for GOP chairmanship

    Gov. Butch Otter withheld comment on the race for Idaho Republican Party chairman, which will be decided next month at the state convention in Moscow.

    Chairman Barry Peterson, with whom Otter has battled over the party's closed primary, platform and control of the state Central Committee, said Wednesday that he's running again.

    Asked whether he would run with or without Otter's support, Peterson smiled and said, "Well, if you can't read it in our body language ... "

    At that moment, after the rally at the Capitol, Otter approached, putting his arm around Peterson.

    "Are we together?" Peterson asked.

    "Yes," replied Otter.

    But when asked whether he will support Peterson for another two years as chairman, Otter demurred.

    "Barry and I haven't talked about tomorrow," he said, Peterson still at his side. "But what I have told him is that I have received calls from several people that are interested in leading the party. ... I'm not endorsing anybody today."

    Former campaign aide Mike Duff, of Blackfoot, has said he's interested in the race. Three more names surfaced Wednesday: retiring Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Luna, former U.S. Attorney and legislator Tom Moss, and Premier Technology President Doug Sayer, a brother of Commerce Director Jeff Sayer.

    Moss and Sayer did not reply to messages Wednesday.

    Said Luna: "I have no plans to run for party chairman. If the governor asked me, I would consider it. I believe the next party chairman should be the person Gov. Otter supports, and I plan to support whoever the governor wants to serve."

  • Fulcher is ready to make dough

    Sen. Russ Fulcher said Wednesday that he has no regrets about attempting to unseat Otter, but it's too soon to say whether he'll seek office again.

    "Coming off of eight months of running with my hair on fire, now is a horrible time to think about that," Fulcher said Wednesday shortly before the GOP rally.

    "You never say never, but I can tell you right now I want to get back into my business and go make some money - because I haven't done that for 10 years in the Senate," he said.

    Fulcher, of Meridian, is a commercial and industrial real estate salesman for Mark Bottles Real Estate in Eagle.

    The campaign was rewarding, Fulcher said.

    "I feel good. I don't regret anything. Whether we try to continue this politically or not, I really don't know. But I can tell you the friendships and relationships I've made across this state are very valuable to me personally. That's not something I'm throwing out," he said.

    "This is a great state, we've got great people here. There's so many of them I just want to grab and say, 'You're going to be OK. Because I'm going to be OK.' "

  • Lori Otter: No fourth term for her

    Should her husband be re-elected to a third term in November, first lady Lori Otter said Wednesday that will be enough for her.

    Asked whether she would support Otter, 72, seeking a fourth term in 2018, she said:

    "I will just say this: I am not running for first lady again. I do not know what the governor is doing."

    Otter has brushed off questions about any plans for 2018, saying he's focused on re-election. He said to ask him on Nov. 5.

Gov. Butch Otter says he's not surprised that state Sen. Russ Fulcher came within 8 percentage points of upsetting him in Tuesday's GOP primary.

Fulcher was "very effective" on issues of concern to Republicans, especially the health insurance exchange and Common Core education standards, Otter said Wednesday.

"It was a very active group against those issues and that base was about 36 percent of the vote," Otter said. "So that was pretty solid."

Otter defeated Fulcher 51.4 percent to 43.6 percent, but lost Ada and Kootenai counties, as well as his native county, Canyon.

"Otter did not receive an overwhelming endorsement from the party faithful," said Northwest Nazarene University's Steve Shaw. "Will this cause Otter to move to the right to try to placate the right wing in his party?"

Democratic nominee A.J. Balukoff said Otter's showing demonstrates his weaknesses.

"Gov. Otter's narrow primary win over a relatively unknown, extremist opponent affirms what I've been hearing as I travel all over Idaho," Balukoff said in a statement. "People like Butch well enough personally, but after almost 40 years as a career politician, it's time for him to retire to his ranch."

Balukoff's landslide margin in his primary victory, 65 percent to 35 percent, wasn't as large as expected over former Republican Terry Kerr, who didn't campaign.


Otter said he decided against making a speech at the election night celebration because Kootenai County returns still hadn't been reported when he left a Boise hotel about 1 a.m.

"I just didn't want to jinx myself," Otter said. "I was concerned that it was close. Russ is a good campaigner, he's a hard campaigner, he's got a lot of talent and enthusiasm."

Fulcher made his congratulatory call to Otter shortly after 7 a.m. Wednesday. He said Otter's strength in rural Idaho might have been decisive. He also thought that winning the state's three biggest counties would have won him Idaho: "I would have said it's a done deal."

Fulcher said he hopes Otter grasped the message of those who voted for change.

"We're trying to figure out how to transition control from government to the people," Fulcher said in an interview. "Hopefully, that's something he'll move forward with."


Otter saluted all GOP candidates, saying they are united in wanting a better economy, better schools and reduced federal influence.

"I agree with every one of them - and, especially, Russ Fulcher," Otter said in introducing his vanquished foe to a rally crowd of about 100.

Fulcher thanked supporters, quoted Ronald Reagan and Theodore Roosevelt, and said, "Primaries are just hard."

Before the speeches, Otter joked with Fulcher about playing golf, saying, "I hope you slice - everything."

Fulcher's endorsement of Otter was more formal than warm.

"It is fitting, it is proper, it is necessary for me to congratulate Gov. Butch Otter, first lady Lori (Otter), the Otter campaign team for their hard work and dedication," Fulcher said.

"Folks, we do disagree on some issues, but we agree on this: Idaho is the best place to live, work, raise a family. Idahoans have the character to lead a nation to prosperity and Republicans have the principles and the will to best get us there. It is an honor. Thank you."

Asked afterward whether "smooth sailing" is ahead for the former rivals, Otter said: "Oh, I don't know if it's smooth sailing, but I'm going to call on Russ and his group and ask them and ask Russ to help me. And he's pledged his help."

Boise State political scientist Gary Moncrief said the campaign revealed weaknesses in the two-term governor's record.

"Fulcher ran a good campaign given the constraints of his limited funding," Moncrief said. "He raised important issues about Otter's record in recent years."

Otter outspent Fulcher by more than 2 to 1.


Otter said he doesn't regret endorsing challengers to five Fulcher allies in the Legislature. One of those allies lost: Sen. Monty Pearce, R-New Plymouth. Sen. Bob Nonini and Reps. Vito Barbieri, Ron Mendive and Kathy Sims, all from Kootenai County, beat Otter-backed challengers.

If Otter is re-elected in November, he said, he expects no problems with those lawmakers. "They follow the same rule that everybody else does: my 24-hour rule. You want to get in to see the governor, you can get in in 24 hours, or get a personal phone call from him," he said.

At least three incumbents backed by Otter lost to challengers from the right: Senate Education Committee Chairman and seven-term Sen. John Goedde, R-Coeur d'Alene; seven-term Rep. George Eskridge, R-Dover; and freshman Rep. Ed Morse, R-Hayden, who had provided a key vote to pass Idaho's health exchange.

But at the rally, Otter heard conciliatory words from a key figure with whom he has clashed: Rep. Lawerence Denney, R-Midvale, who won a four-way race for the secretary of state nomination.

"You know, we disagree on very, very few issues," Denney said at the Capitol. "And some of those things we disagree on vehemently, but we can disagree and still agree on the majority of things. Certainly, if we can agree on 80 percent of the things, we can all come together and we can bring this party back together."

After the rally, Otter sought out Denney, slapping him on the back and conferring on campaign signs and strategy for the fall, when Denney faces Democratic Rep. Holli Woodings, of Boise.

"I've not agreed to any debates until after Labor Day," Otter told Denney.

Dan Popkey: 377-6438

Idaho Statesman is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service

Top Jobs

View All Top Jobs

Find a Home

$1,600,000 Boise
4 bed, 4.5 full bath. Incredible opportunity to own this...

Find a Car

Search New Cars