Don't like your doctor? How to make a clean break


Changing docs ILLUS.jpg


The last time I saw my gynecologist, she glossed over the issue I’d come in for and gave me a test I didn’t want — without even discussing it with me first. In my previous visit, she ordered me a mammogram and brushed off my attempts to discuss the exam’s harms and benefits. It’s clear we have a communication problem, and frankly I’m ready to fire her — but how? Am I obligated to tell her I’m switching doctors? (I’d feel badly if she found out by reading it in this column.) And what obligations does she have to me?

It’s okay to just leave without notifying your doctor, says Michael Pramenko, past president of the Colorado Medical Society and executive director at Primary Care Partners in Grand Junction, the city where I get my medical care. Most physician codes of ethics suggest 30 days as a reasonable amount of time to provide emergency care — but not appointments for routine care — while the patient finds another physician, says Reid B. Blackwelder, president of the American Academy of Family Physicians.

Before you move on, you should consider speaking to the office manager. Many practices would want to know if one of their providers isn’t doing a good job, especially if the problem is severe enough to send you elsewhere, Pramenko says.

If you don’t feel comfortable giving feedback face to face, consider sending a letter that explains why you’re changing doctors, Blackwelder says. If the problems with your physician include unprofessional or incompetent behavior, then the appropriate response is to report it directly to your state’s medical board, Blackwelder says.

Once you have decided to leave, be sure to request a copy of your medical records. You can have them sent either to you or directly to your new doctor. Ask that they include lab results and such things as MRIs, X-rays, EKGs and recent hospital records, Blackwelder says. If your doctor has sent you to a specialist, it’s a good idea to ask for copies of the consultation notes from these visits too, he says. Legally, the records belong to your doctor, but as a patient you have a right to a copy, says Rachel Seeger of the Office for Civil Rights at the Department of Health and Human Services.

In some cases, the best approach is to go to the front desk and request your records yourself. Under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, the doctor must comply with your request. You may have to pay for the copies and printouts, but HIPAA mandates that a practice may charge only “reasonable,” cost-based fees. Blackwelder says a fee of $20 is common, but the price can climb rapidly if you have an extensive medical record.

If you’re taking medications, you’ll want to renew your prescriptions before you leave your current doctor’s care and make sure you can see your new doctor before your drugs run out, Blackwelder says.

How do you find a new doctor that’s a good match? Start by seeking references, Pramenko says. While you can find physician ratings on sites such as the one run by Healthgrades, keep in mind that these tend to come from people who either really love or really hate their doctor, he says.

You can check a doctor’s credentials at the American Medical Association’s Doctor Finder website. But the best way to find a doctor is by word of mouth, says Pramenko says. It’s okay to call the practice and ask some basic questions about the doctor’s policies, Blackwelder says, but it might be hard to determine in advance more subtle things such as a physician’s communication style.

Idaho Statesman is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service