I Just Work Here

I Just Work Here by Rex Huppke: Saving career loyalty in an evolving free-for-all job market

Rex Huppke is the workplace columnist for the Chicago TribuneJune 4, 2013 

HUPPKE REX TB

Rex Huppke

BILL HOGAN — MCT

So, job candidate, where do you see yourself in five years?

Yes, I know that's the worst interview question ever invented. But what's your answer?

What's that? It sounded like you said, "Elsewhere." Oh, that is what you said? In five years you see yourself elsewhere? Well, at least you're honest.

The concept of workers spending decades at one company isn't dead, but it is, at best, infirm. Economic pressures and the rapid pace of technology make long-term loyalty - from employer and employee - increasingly unrealistic.

In a new issue of the Harvard Business Review (I read it mainly for the erotic bar graphs), there's a spot-on article called "Tours of Duty: The New Employer-Employee Compact."

The authors write about the effect of globalization and the Information Age: "Stability gave way to rapid, unpredictable change. Adaptability and entrepreneurship became key to achieving and sustaining success. These changes demolished the traditional employer-employee compact and its accompanying career escalator in the U.S. private sector."

They suggest companies hire people into two- to four-year "tours of duty." Maybe it's the development of a new product or work on a specific project with a defined timeline. The experience will help the employee develop in his or her career, and the company will get the best out of a motivated employee.

After the tour is up, both sides reassess - the worker might stay for another tour or leave for another opportunity. Either way, it will have been a win-win.

I spoke with one of the article's authors, Chris Yeh, vice president of marketing for PBworks, a California-based company that helps businesses operate more effectively, and he said this approach refines the definition of workplace loyalty based on present circumstances.

"Work endeavors used to take longer, so you needed the tight bonds and loyalty, you needed the coherence to create something that might take longer than a human lifetime," Yeh said. "Whereas today you could create an entire company and sell it within 18 months. So I think the concept of tours of duty gives both a compression of loyalty and an expansion of loyalty. You have this very intense period of time where you are really completely in it."

The other ideas Yeh and his co-authors present involve greater openness. They say employees should be encouraged to build networks outside their own companies, and businesses should maintain good relationships with former workers, creating strong alumni networks.

External networks are being developed via social media, whether it's LinkedIn or Twitter. So why shouldn't companies embrace that with the hope of benefiting from the exchange of knowledge? It's a "rising tide lifts all ships" way of thinking.

I certainly don't expect everyone to start having careers that are a patchwork of short-term gigs. But ideas like "tours of duty" help us think about the realities of the working world. They bring into focus the idea that a job should be a mutually beneficial experience. Hopefully with a clear vision, the experiences and opportunities that employees desire will line up better with what companies provide.

And five years from now we can see ourselves where we'd like to be: employed and happy.

rhuppke@tribune.comTwitter: @RexWorksHere

Idaho Statesman is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service