Rocky Barker: Geysers' fate may rest in Idaho caldera

Idaho StatesmanJune 3, 2013 

Old Faithful in 1999.

PETE ZIMOWSKY — Idaho Statesman file

The Park Service is holding a conference Monday through Wednesday to examine the science surrounding the Old Faithful Geyser.

Park officials want to know what science is out there to guide them in protecting the national shrine, which is just miles from the Idaho border. The focus, though, is only the immediate area of the world's most dependable geyser - a place that about a quarter of Americans will visit in their lifetime, according to a poll.

Protecting Old Faithful and Yellowstone's thousands of other thermal features - some right on the border with Idaho - is one of the arguments for the proposed Idaho Yellowstone Caldera National Monument studied by former Interior Secretary Dirk Kempthorne.

Concerns about geothermal development in what is called the Island Park Known Geothermal Resource Area for power or heating led the U.S. Forest Service and the Bureau of Land Management to do an environmental impact statement on development in the 1970s, when Cecil Andrus was Interior secretary. Occidental Petroleum Co. was one of several energy companies interested in exploring the Island Park Caldera area to determine if the geothermal resource could be tapped.

Just as Andrus was getting ready to walk out of the door at Interior in 1980 and return to Idaho, the final decision was made to ban all geothermal leasing in the Island Park Geothermal Area. But the EIS itself said such a ban still left private land and state lands in the area open to geothermal development.

This came up in the early 1990s, when the Church Universal and Triumphant announced plans for a development in Corwin Springs, on its land north of Yellowstone in Montana. A bill was written, the Old Faithful Protection Act, to try to stop it.

One of the act's strongest supporters was Irving Friedman, a geochemist with the U.S. Geological Survey who was an expert on Yellowstone's natural geothermal plumbing. He wanted to ban geothermal development not only at Corwin Springs but all around Yellowstone, especially in Island Park.

"We should not be playing roulette with Yellowstone's geyser system," Friedman would say.

His bosses did not always like his activist efforts and tried to shut him up. But Friedman had been a legendary member of a group of post-doctoral researchers in a laboratory of Harold Urey, a Nobel laureate, at the University of Chicago in the 1940s. Friedman's work there earned him the title of "father of isotope hydrology."

I went to Kamchatka with Friedman in 1992, part of a scientific group that went to look at Russia's Far East after the Soviet Union went away.

Kamchatka has active geysers, though natural landslides have buried many of them since. Friedman walked with me through a beautiful hot springs area with all kinds of fumaroles and bubbling mud pots but no geysers.

Southern Kamchatka's geysers had disappeared after a geothermal electric plant was built nearby in 1966, Friedman said. He didn't want the same thing to happen in Island Park.

When Friedman died in 2005 at age 85, Yellowstone Science Magazine called him "Yellowstone's geothermal soul."

Louisa Willcox, an environmental activist who went with us on the 1992 trip, said even after Montana resolved the Corwin Springs threat she continued to worry about Island Park.

"It just takes some ambitious person or industry who decides they want to punch into some hot water and develop a spa to bring the threat back up front," said Willcox, of Livingston, Mont. "It's bigger than protecting the geysers. It's about protecting the trumpeter swans and the other birds who depend on the year-round open water from the thermal features."

Designating the Island Park Caldera as a national monument would provide eastern Idaho with an economic shot in the arm, by keeping Yellowstone visitors in Idaho for an extra day and adding passengers at the Idaho Falls Airport. No one is talking about cutting back snowmobiling or any outdoor activity that isn't already regulated to protect grizzly bears and other wildlife.

But protecting Yellowstone's geysers is reason enough for national action. Irving Friedman would agree.

Rocky Barker: 377-6484

Idaho Statesman is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service