Family sues Meridian hospital over father's death

The suit alleges the Nampa man was overmedicated as if he was being administered end-of-life care.

kmoeller@idahostatesman.comApril 21, 2013 

James Dorsey, pictured in 2010 with granddaughter Chloe, now 5. He lived close to his son in Nampa and acted as a full-time caretaker for his grandchildren when his son was at work.

PROVIDED BY DORSEY FAMILY

  • $50 MILLION TORT CLAIM FILED AGAINST THE STATE

    On March 6, 2012, the Dorsey family filed a tort claim, putting the state on notice that it planned to sue the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare for $50 million. The claim alleged that the agency - which licenses and certifies health care facilities - took "inadequate action" when it found "prior deficiencies which contributed to deaths of patients" at Complex Care.

    Detailed here are two previous complaints against Complex Care of Idaho in Meridian that were filed with the state.

    - 2010: Investigators substantiated three of many allegations: A patient who was supposed to be resuscitated was treated as a "do not resuscitate" patient and subsequently died. There was confusion among staff at the hospital as to patient code status. A patient was burned by a heating pad.

    Allegations (not substantiated): Inadequate nursing staff, inexperienced nurses in the ER, excessive medication error, patient with decubitus ulcers, large number of falls, and staff did not watch monitors.

    - 2011: Investigators substantiated one of many allegations: Patient's needs not attended to in a timely manner.

    Allegations (not substantiated): Facility doesn't contact family members when patient's medications are changed significantly. Also, facility did not facilitate consultation with a specialist as promised before admission.

    Dorsey's attorney, Michael Hanby, said a lawsuit still may be filed against the Health and Welfare Department.

    Why $50 million? "My mom came up with a number for every hour my dad suffered," Jim Dorsey said. "Will they every pay that? No, you know that. We want to bring this to the public's attention."

    The state cap for monetary judgments against public agencies is $500,000 for both economic and noneconomic damages, regardless of the number of claimants. There's also a $310,000 cap on noneconomic damages - pain and suffering - for any single claimant. "How can you put a number on your mom or your dad?" Dorsey asked.

  • HOW DOES IDAHO DEFINE COMFORT CARE?

    Title 39, Health and Safety; Chapter 45, The Medical Consent and Natural Death Act Individuals caring for a patient for whom artificial life-sustaining procedures or artificially administered nutrition and hydration are withheld or withdrawn shall provide comfort care as defined in section 39-4502:

    "Comfort care" means treatment and care to provide comfort and cleanliness.

    It includes:

    (a) Oral and body hygiene;

    (b) Reasonable efforts to offer food and fluids orally;

    (c) Medication, positioning, warmth, appropriate lighting and other measures to relieve pain and suffering; and

    (d) Privacy and respect for the dignity and humanity of the patient.

  • ABOUT KATY MOELLER

    Katy has worked in newspapers for 19 years. She's a generalist who enjoys writing about issues that affect people's daily lives.

James Dorsey led a full and active life, his final years spent helping care for his grandchildren and enjoying big family dinners.

The 70-year-old died Sept. 12, 2011 at Complex Care of Idaho in Meridian. His family believes he died unnecessarily because of medical negligence.

After surgery for lung cancer, his family says, he was moved to the long-term acute care hospital in Meridian that treated him as if he were dying rather than recovering. They say a physician changed Dorsey's status to "do not resuscitate" without Dorsey or his wife signing off, initiated end-of-life "comfort care" without consulting the family and prescribed fatal doses of pain-killing drugs.

The experience sent the Nampa man's son, Jim, a 44-year-old former restaurateur, on a 1 1/2-year crusade to meticulously and relentlessly gather documents and search for evidence to prove that his father did not die a natural - or accidental - death.

In a lawsuit filed last week against Complex Care of Idaho and two physicians, the family alleges medical malpractice and wrongful death.

The lawsuit says the actions of the physicians and hospital were illegal, constituting a felony crime such as homicide, manslaughter, administering poison with intent to kill, assisting a suicide or euthanasia.

The original death certificate completed by Complex Care's Dr. Jamia E. Byrns listed Dorsey's death as "natural," caused by right lower lobe pneumonia.

But after an autopsy, the Ada County Coroner's Office voided the death certificate and issued a new one. The cause of death was listed as combined drug overdose (lorazepam and morphine). The manner was listed as "accident."

CLEAN RECORDS

If the plaintiffs' attorneys can prove that the hospital staff's conduct leading up to Dorsey's death was willful, reckless or a felony under state law, state caps on non-economic damages of about $310,000 don't apply.

Meridian police said they concluded that no crime occurred and did not investigate the death.

Randy Evaro, administrator for Complex Care of Idaho, didn't return calls for comment last week.

Byrns is one physician named as a defendant; the other is Dr. Julie D. Lyon. Both are now employed as hospital-based physicians at St. Luke's Boise Medical Center. Through a hospital spokesman, they declined an opportunity to comment.

Neither physician has a record of disciplinary action by the state, according to the Idaho Board of Medicine's online database. The board does not disclose active investigations, said Nancy Kerr, executive director of the Board of Medicine.

FAMILY CONFRONTATION

Dorsey was transferred to Complex Care from Saint Alphonsus Regional Medical Center, where he'd undergone surgery to remove a cancerous tumor from his right lung. He was at Saint Al's for about six weeks before he was transferred to Complex Care, a long-term acute care hospital.

Four days into Dorsey's six-day stay at Complex Care, his family says, they became alarmed when the hospital stopped medical treatment and initiated an aggressive regimen of pain-killing drugs.

"I said, 'Wait, if you're not going to give him any care, then I'm going to take him home,'" Dorsey's wife, Jacinta, told the Statesman.

Dr. Byrns strongly rejected the idea of releasing Dorsey from the hospital, she said.

"If I tried to take him out AMA (against medical advice), she said she'd call the cops," Jacinta Dorsey said.

Attorney and former Canyon County Prosecutor Dave Young, a Dorsey family friend who was at the hospital to offer support, said he heard the confrontation and shouting over Dorsey's medical care down the hallway.

Young said he arranged to have Dorsey transferred back to Saint Alphonsus Regional Medical Center the next morning - but that never happened, and he never got an explanation from Complex Care staff about why not.

ALLEVIATING PAIN OR ENDING A LIFE?

When Saint Al's discharged Dorsey, its summary indicated Dorsey had failed "swallow evaluations" and was put on a feeding tube due to risk of drawing substances into his respiratory tract.

"Mr. Dorsey did participate in physical therapy and ambulated in the halls with a walker; he was limited due to his higher oxygenation requirements and also his deconditioned state," the discharge report says.

When James Dorsey arrived at Complex Care, Lyon performed the patient history and exam, according to the lawsuit. Dr. Byrns got involved in his care four days later.

The lawsuit alleges that Byrns prescribed, administered or dispensed medications that she knew, or should have known, would cause Dorsey's death.

Medical records show numerous increases in dosages of morphine and lorazepam during the night before and morning of Dorsey's death, according to the suit. He lost consciousness after the initial administration of drugs and never again awoke, according to the family.

"There's no justifiable reason for that - the goal (of comfort care) isn't to keep a patient unconscious," said the plaintiffs' attorney, Michael Hanby. He said even if a patient is at death's door, the goal of comfort care is to keep the person comfortable, not unconscious.

"He wasn't in that immense amount of pain where he required that kind of medication to be comfortable," Hanby said. He said an expert told attorneys that the combined dosage Dorsey received was enough to kill an elephant.

"There was an effort to end life rather than alleviate pain," said Hanby. "There was no mistake here. Dr. Byrns ordered what she ordered. The administration of medications comes from the medical records."

STATE INVESTIGATION INTO ALLEGATIONS

After Dorsey died, his family notified the Ada County Coroner's Office that the hospital had administered drugs against their wishes and, they believed, caused his death. The coroner conducted an autopsy before the body was cremated.

The family filed a complaint about Complex Care with the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare, triggering an investigation in 2011.

State health investigators did an unannounced survey from Oct. 31 to Nov. 3. Hospital staff and five patients were interviewed, and medical records of 13 patients were reviewed, according to the report from the investigation.

The national medical director for Complex Care of Idaho's parent organization was interviewed about medication administered as part of "comfort care," according to the investigation report.

"He stated the use of Ativan and morphine IV drips did not have a maximum dose limit for comfort care patients," the report says. "He stated the right dose is variable between patients and as an (individual patient) adapts."

State investigators found "insufficient evidence" to substantiate any of the allegations of improper care made by the Dorseys. The report offered this caveat:

"When the allegation is referred to as unsubstantiated, it means that noncompliance with a regulation could not be proven. It does not mean that an incident did not occur or that a family member/visitor did not witness a problem. It means that an allegation could not be confirmed through the investigation process or the facility took corrective measures prior to the investigation."

POLICE, CORONER SEE NO EVIDENCE OF CRIME

Jim Dorsey tried to file a police report with the Meridian Police Department, and he talked to officials there on numerous occasions.

"There is nothing there for us to go on that would indicate anything criminal," Meridian Police Deputy Chief Tracy Basterrechea said last year. "There's no report to be filed, if there's no criminal conduct."

The Dorsey family's request for a coroner's inquest was denied. Coroner Erwin Sonnenberg said his office didn't find anything to indicate a crime had occurred.

A coroner's inquest - impaneling a jury to investigate a death, ordered at the discretion of the coroner - is expensive, time-consuming and rare. The last Ada County inquest was in 2005, involving a high-profile officer-involved shooting of a 16-year-old boy.

Undeterred, Jim Dorsey has filed complaints with the Drug Enforcement Administration and the Idaho Board of Medicine.

The Board of Medicine receives 280 to 300 complaints each year, according to Kerr, the executive director. Before a medical malpractice lawsuit can be filed, the complainant must go to a prelitigation panel.

About 120 cases go to such panels each year in Idaho. Kerr said the three-member panels typically have an attorney hearing officer, a physician and a lay member of the public.

Both sides get to present to the panel, which makes a recommendation to the parties about the merits. The outcome is confidential: It is not shared with the Idaho Board of Medicine or anyone else.

"The purpose is to eliminate frivolous suits," Kerr said, noting also that it offers an opportunity for settlement.

Katy Moeller: 377-6413

Idaho Statesman is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service