Dear Bosses: Youre doing it wrong.
Sincerely,
The Employees
OK, that might be a slight generalization of the way many workers feel about their leaders. But I dont think its far off, and I conveniently have some data to back that up.
Consider these numbers from a new survey by Harris Interactive and talent management company Development Dimensions International:
34 percent of workers dont think their boss is effective.
60 percent say their boss sometimes damages their self-esteem.
Half of workers say their boss doesnt ask for ideas about how to solve problems.
Theres clearly a problem here, and its not that humans who obtain the title of boss immediately become insufferable jerkfaces. The root of the problem is Communication. (Thats Communication with a capital C and that rhymes with B and that stands for Boy, does my boss stink.)
Pete Weaver, senior vice president of leadership solutions at Development Dimensions International, said he sees bosses and managers focused too much on knowledge and not enough on skill in other words, we have smart, well-educated leaders who arent adept at delivering information.
The ability to lead people means having skill at communication and interactions, Weaver said.
While we are all equipped with mouths and minds and a shared language, we tend to be rather bad at communicating. Thats true in all realms, from family life to the workplace, but failures to connect can be particularly pronounced in a boss/employee relationship.
I spoke with Ben Benjamin, a communications consultant and co-author of the book Conversation Transformation, which examines an array of destructive communication patterns.
Everybody who talks communicates, but most people communicate badly most of the time, Benjamin said.
One of the most common mistakes business leaders make is asking leading questions, like: Do you really think people will buy that product? or This is what our main focus should be, right?
These questions are part opinion, part inquiry. They leave the employee with two crummy choices:
Give the answer you think the boss wants, even if its not what you think.
Give an answer that conflicts with the boss thinking, which can feel risky and uncomfortable.
Leaders and employees, as communication is a two-way street need to recognize how flawed it is to phrase questions this way.
Instead, ask broad questions that are open-ended and solicit information or opinions. Or ask narrow ones that elicit facts or a simple yes or no.
If youre on the receiving end of a leading question, Benjamin suggests addressing it in two parts. If somebody says, Dont you think we should wait a few weeks? say something like, It sounds like you think we should wait a few weeks and you want to know if I agree. Is that correct?
Another major communication pitfall is the yes/but question. Yes, I like this advice column youre writing, but are you sure you should have used the word jerkface?
Benjamin noted that this question format is, in essence, a scolding: Its really arguing with the person rather than saying something specific.
The broad point here is that bosses and managers need to put more thought into the things they say. Think forward a few steps. Consider your phrasing. Give thought to the way you speak, bosses.
REX HUPPKE Chicago Tribune workplace columnist
rexhuppke@tribune.com


Words at Work by Kathy McIntosh: A communication checkup offers preventive word care

